Facebook
MenuShow site menu

Repair or Replace

Home > Repair or Replace

We Can Help

DAYS, NIGHTS, WEEKENDS

Should I repair it or replace it?

That’s the biggest – and most important – question you’ll ever ask regarding your heating and cooling systems. And there are so many questions within the question:

  • When is equipment considered too old?
  • Will a newer system get you the energy efficiency you’re looking for to justify the cost?
  • If you repair or upgrade your system, are you just throwing good money at old, out-dated equipment?

We’d be happy to come to your home and personally assess your current situation and make thoughtful, in writing, easy to understand recommendations.

Key Considerations When Deciding Whether to Repair or Replace:
  • Your furnace, air conditioner unit or heat pump is more than 15 years old. Consider replacing it with a unit that has earned the “Energy Star” label. Installed correctly, these high-efficiency units can save up to 50% on heating and cooling costs.
  • Your equipment needs frequent repairs and your energy bills are going up. Your cooling or heating equipment is not cooling or heating as quickly and efficiently as it once did.
  • Uneven temperatures throughout your home. Some rooms being too hot or too cold may indicate a failing system or ductwork issues.
  • Your home lacks a programmable thermostat. This can lead to unnecessary energy waste, especially when no one is home.
  • Humidity problems in your home. Poor equipment operation, inadequate equipment, or leaky ductwork can cause overly dry air in winter and excess humidity in summer.
  • Unusual noises coming from your system. Noisy operation may signal problems like an undersized duct system or other issues with the furnace or air conditioner. New units have much lower sound ratings and highly efficient motors that allow for quieter operation.
Warning Signs of a Serious Issue:
  • Flame rollouts in a gas furnace. If flames extend outside the burner or combustion chamber, this is a fire hazard. It often happens due to soot buildup, corrosion, or a cracked heat exchanger. Flame sensors can shut down the unit to prevent damage, but a professional inspection is crucial for safety.
  • Humming or buzzing noises from your air conditioner. This could indicate issues such as a seized condenser fan motor, loose components, a malfunctioning circuit breaker, a failing contactor relay switch, or a frozen unit. Ignoring these sounds could lead to costly damage or even pose a safety risk.
What to Do Next:

If you notice any of these warning signs, turn off your system and call an HVAC professional immediately. Attempting DIY repairs can be dangerous due to electrical components and refrigerants. At Hartman Brothers Heating & Air Conditioning, we’re here to help ensure your home stays safe and comfortable. Contact us today for an expert evaluation of your heating and cooling system.

Satisfied Clients

Our Number One Goal

Flurish


★ ★ ★ ★ ★

"Extremely pleased with their work! When I say I'm a picky customer, I really mean it (I'm a Training Manager for an HVAC manufacturer). These guys showed up precisely on time, were extremely courteous and professional, and did an outstanding job on my system. They were very careful moving the equipment to my mechanical room (not an easy task), did a very neat job on the install, and cleaned up so that everything was spotless when they left. I even gave them an opportunity to do a "shortcut" on my install, but they refused and said "that's not the way we do it." It was easy to tell that these techs took PRIDE in the work they were doing. I can't even begin to tell you how much I would recommend this small business from New Haven, IN to do any HVAC work. If you want a courteous, professional install at a reasonable price, call Hartman Bros!"

— Jay Hammond
(Google Review)

★ ★ ★ ★ ★

"On Saturday, my water heater spewed lots of water in the utility portion of my garage. Unfortunately, my furnace was soaked. After my call to Hartman Bros., Darian arrived within the hour and dried out the furnace and re-started it. Hartman Bros. has been servicing my heating and cooling systems for over 30 years and have always been "johnny-on-the-spot" when I have had problems. I highly recommend them."

— Nancee L.
(Google Review)

★ ★ ★ ★ ★

"We were so impressed with our repairman! He explained everything very thoroughly of what repairs he needed to make to help our furnace to run more efficient. Also, when we called for a repairman, he was at our house within 30 minutes! WOW!"

— Jeffrey M.
(Google Review)

★ ★ ★ ★ ★

"Hartman brothers are always fantastic, they have always taken care of us, Ked came over and had our heat back up and running in an hour, always friendly and courteous. Thank you for a job well done."

— Chris D.
(Google Review)

★ ★ ★ ★ ★

"Have used this company for many years, always excellent service."

— Charlene F.
(Google Review)

★ ★ ★ ★ ★

"Hartman Brothers has always given me great service. I feel comfortable knowing they are taking care of my heating and ac needs. Everyone is responsible, and I am very comfortable with all of the techs taking care of my maintenance even when I'm not home."

— Shelly K.
(Google Review)

★ ★ ★ ★ ★

"Every thing went well, even though he had bad news that the unit needed to be replaced due to the fact that the unit was 18 years old and the refrigerant used in the day was R22 that it cant be purchased because of government regulations, now we will see what the estimate will be. The technician seems to be knowledgeable and was very professional about his work."

— Harold Breames
(Google Review)

★ ★ ★ ★ ★

"Thank you for fixing my furnace tonight!! It's cold and will be colder tomorrow night... I knew I made the right decision having you install my furnace and air conditioning. You are awesome!! I love my generator that you installed as well!"

— Cheryl Kensill
(Facebook Review)

Contact Us

Call Today to Schedule with Us

Call

1 (260) 493-4402


Location

535 Green Street
New Haven, IN 46774

Email

service@hartmanbrothers.com

© 2026 Hartman Brothers Heating & Air Conditioning, Inc. All Rights Reserved ®

Website Powered by Skagga Inc. Marketing   |   Terms of Use